Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Squirrels & Wildlife

Dairy Goat Breeds — 6 Compared on Yield and Butterfat

Dairy goat breeds trade volume against butterfat, and that decides taste. 6 compared on yield, richness and size. See which suits your holding.

By Salma 3 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.

Saanen goat
Photo: Sanoopsanu92, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
On this page

Saanen for volume, Nubian for richness, Nigerian Dwarf for small spaces, Alpine if you want one answer. The rest of the decision is temperament, climate and how much noise your neighbours will tolerate.

The comparison

Yield against richness, which is the real trade
BreedYieldButterfatSizeNotes
SaanenHighest~3%LargeNeeds shade, sunburns
AlpineHigh~3.5%LargeHardy, adaptable, assertive
ToggenburgGood~3.2%MediumHardiest. Divisive flavour
OberhasliGood~3.9%MediumCalm, attractive, less common
LaManchaGood~3.9%Med-largeCalmest temperament
NubianModerate4–5%LargeVery loud. Heat tolerant
Nigerian DwarfLow6%+SmallBest for small plots
Mini breeds (crosses)Low-mod4–6%SmallMiddle ground
Guernsey / GoldenModerate~3.7%MediumRare, golden milk
SableHigh~3.5%LargeA coloured Saanen, tolerates sun better

Volume is usually not the constraint

The instinct is to compare milk yields first. For a household it is rarely the number that matters.

A single full-size doe at peak gives two to four litres a day. That is more than most families drink, before any thought of cheese. Lactation runs around 280 to 305 days, so the practical question quickly becomes what to do with the surplus rather than how to get more.

Which is why butterfat turns out to be the more useful figure. It determines how the milk tastes, how much cheese a litre yields, and how much butter you can make — and butterfat is where the breeds genuinely differ.

Two goats, minimum, before anything else

Goats are herd animals. A single goat kept alone is loud, stressed, escape-prone and difficult in every way.

A companion does not have to be a second milker — a wether is inexpensive and uncomplicated. But the space, fencing and feed must be planned for two from the start.

Choosing by what actually constrains you

Small property, one person handling them → Nigerian Dwarf, or a mini breed

You want cheese → Nigerian Dwarf or Nubian, for butterfat

Cold wet climate → Toggenburg, or Alpine

Hot climate → Nubian, or Sable rather than Saanen

Close neighbours → anything but Nubian

Children involved, or first goats → LaMancha, or Oberhasli

Selling milk, or feeding stock → Saanen or Alpine

One answer without thinking about it → Alpine

What breed cannot fix

Three things matter more than which breed you buy, and all three are management:

Nutrition. A doe on poor forage produces far less than her breed’s figures regardless of genetics. Good pasture or hay, appropriate minerals — particularly copper, where goats differ from sheep — and clean water do more for yield than any breed choice.

Handling and milk hygiene. Milk filtered and chilled quickly tastes clean; milk cooled slowly develops the tang people call goaty. A buck housed near the does taints the milk whatever breed they are. See best tasting goat milk breed for the detail.

Fencing. Goats test everything. The most common reason people give up on goats has nothing to do with milk and everything to do with finding them in the neighbour’s garden for the fourth time.

Buying

  • Buy from a producer, not a sale barn, and see the mother milked if you can
  • Ask about lactation records if they are kept
  • Buy two, from the same place where possible
  • Check udder attachment and teat size — teat size in particular determines whether hand milking is pleasant or miserable
  • Have the fencing finished before the goats arrive, not after

Our picks

#PickBest forWhere to buy
1SaanenHighest yield Check price for Saanen →
2NubianRichest milk of the full-size breeds Check price for Nubian →
3Nigerian DwarfBest for small properties Check price for Nigerian Dwarf →
4AlpineBest all-rounder
5LaManchaCalmest temperament
6ToggenburgHardiest

Highest yield

Saanen

Buy for volume if you are selling milk or feeding stock. More milk than a household can drink, and the least rich.

Yield
Highest of all dairy breeds
Butterfat
~3%
Size
Large, 60–90 kg
Temperament
Calm, docile

What we liked

  • The production breed — most milk of any dairy goat
  • Calm, easy to handle and to milk
  • Long, steady lactations

Worth knowing

  • Lowest butterfat, so mild thin milk and less cheese per litre
  • Pale skin burns easily; needs genuine shade
  • Large animals need more feed and stronger fencing
Check current price (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)

Richest milk of the full-size breeds

Nubian

The flavour choice among full-size goats, and the one most likely to generate a complaint about noise.

Yield
Moderate
Butterfat
4–5%
Size
Large
Temperament
Affectionate, extremely vocal

What we liked

  • High butterfat gives sweet, creamy milk and good cheese yield
  • Handles heat better than the Swiss breeds
  • Affectionate and people-oriented

Worth knowing

  • Genuinely loud — a serious consideration with close neighbours
  • Lower volume than Saanen or Alpine
Check current price (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)

Best for small properties

Nigerian Dwarf

What we would keep on a small plot. Richer milk than a Nubian in a goat you can pick up.

Yield
0.7–1.5 L/day
Butterfat
6%+
Size
Small, 20–34 kg
Temperament
Friendly, manageable

What we liked

  • Highest butterfat of the common dairy breeds
  • One person can handle them easily
  • Less space, less feed, lighter on pasture
  • Often breed year-round rather than seasonally

Worth knowing

  • Low absolute volume — two does are often needed
  • Small teats make hand milking fiddly at first
Check current price (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)

Best all-rounder

Alpine

The sensible default for a working herd. Hardy, productive and adaptable, without excelling at any one thing.

Yield
High
Butterfat
~3.5%
Size
Large
Temperament
Hardy, independent, assertive

What we liked

  • Strong production over long lactations
  • Very adaptable to varied climates and conditions
  • Hardy and generally trouble-free

Worth knowing

  • Assertive — tends to dominate a mixed herd
  • Mid-range butterfat, so neither the richest nor the most productive

Calmest temperament

LaMancha

Underrated. If temperament matters most — children, first goats, limited handling experience — start here.

Yield
Good
Butterfat
~3.9%
Size
Medium-large
Temperament
Notably calm and tolerant

What we liked

  • Widely regarded as the easiest dairy breed to handle
  • Good butterfat with solid production
  • Long lactations, often holding milk well

Worth knowing

  • The very small ears are divisive and sometimes mistaken for a defect
  • Less widely available than Nubian or Alpine

Hardiest

Toggenburg

The choice for a cold wet climate where other breeds struggle. Flavour divides opinion more than with other breeds.

Yield
Good
Butterfat
~3.2%
Size
Medium
Temperament
Hardy, independent

What we liked

  • Extremely hardy, including in cold damp climates
  • Consistent, persistent milkers
  • One of the oldest established dairy breeds

Worth knowing

  • Lower butterfat, and milk sometimes described as stronger flavoured
  • Independent-minded and less biddable than LaMancha or Saanen

Common questions

Which dairy goat breed produces the most milk?

Saanens, consistently — they are the Holstein of the goat world, bred for volume, and a good doe produces substantially more than any other breed. Alpines are close behind and are more adaptable to varied conditions and climates. The caveat is that volume is rarely the limiting factor for a household: even a modest doe produces well over what one family drinks, so the questions that matter in practice are usually butterfat, temperament and how much land and shelter you have.

Which dairy goat is best for a small property?

Nigerian Dwarfs, for most people. They are small enough to be handled easily by one person, need less space and less feed, and produce milk with the highest butterfat of any common dairy breed, which makes it excellent for cheese. The trade-offs are that absolute yield is low so two does are often needed, and their small teats make hand milking fiddly until you are used to them. Mini versions of the full-size breeds — Mini Nubians and similar — occupy a middle ground.

What is a good milk yield for a dairy goat?

Roughly two to four litres a day at peak for a well-managed full-size doe, falling through the lactation, with Saanens and Alpines at the upper end and Nubians lower but richer. A Nigerian Dwarf gives perhaps 0.7 to 1.5 litres. Lactation typically runs around 280 to 305 days. Those figures assume good feeding and management — a doe on poor forage produces far less regardless of breed, and breed choice cannot compensate for inadequate nutrition.

Which dairy goats are easiest to keep?

Alpines and Toggenburgs are generally considered the hardiest and most adaptable of the full-size breeds, handling varied climates and less than perfect conditions well. Saanens are docile and easy to handle but are prone to sunburn and dislike strong sun, so they need shade. Nubians are heat-tolerant and affectionate but notably loud, which is a genuine consideration near neighbours. LaManchas have a reputation as among the calmest and most tolerant of handling.

Do you need two goats?

Yes. Goats are herd animals and a single goat kept alone is genuinely distressed — noisy, stressed, prone to escaping, and harder to manage in every respect. Two is the practical minimum, and a companion does not have to be another milker; a wether makes an inexpensive and uncomplicated companion. This is the first thing to plan around, because it doubles the space, fencing and feed requirement before any milk is produced.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading