Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Squirrels & Wildlife

Best Tasting Goat Milk Breed — 4 Compared on Butterfat

The best tasting goat milk breed is Nubian, on butterfat. 4 breeds compared, plus the handling that matters more. See which suits your holding.

By Zakaria 2 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you.

On this page

Nubian, because butterfat carries flavour. But handling beats breed — mishandled Nubian milk tastes worse than carefully handled Saanen.

Why butterfat is the flavour question

The four common dairy breeds
BreedButterfatVolumeFlavour
Nigerian Dwarf6%+Low (high for size)Richest
Nubian4–5%ModerateRich, sweet
Alpine~3.5%HighMild, clean
Saanen~3%HighestMildest, thinnest

Fat carries flavour compounds and gives milk body. It also determines how much cheese or butter a litre yields, which matters more than the drinking glass for most smallholders.

The “goaty” taste is usually not the goat

A buck near the does taints the milk

This is the single most common cause of strongly goaty milk, and it has nothing to do with breed. The compounds responsible for a buck’s smell transfer into the milk of does housed near him.

House bucks separately and well away, especially during the rut.

The rest of it is handling. Goat milk absorbs odours readily and its fat globules are small and fragile:

  1. Filter immediately after milking
  2. Chill fast — an ice bath beats a fridge shelf. Slow cooling is where the tang develops
  3. Seal it. Milk stored near strong-smelling food picks it up
  4. Clean equipment rigorously
  5. Watch the feed — brassicas, wild garlic and some silages carry straight through

Done properly, milk from any of these breeds tastes clean and sweet. Done badly, none of them does.

Choosing for a household

  • Cheese and richness, full-size goat → Nubian
  • Small plot, one person handling them → Nigerian Dwarf
  • Volume with mild flavour → Alpine
  • Maximum milk → Saanen

And one practical warning that has nothing to do with milk: Nubians are loud. Genuinely, persistently loud. On a small plot with close neighbours that is worth weighing against the butterfat.

Our picks

#PickBest forWhere to buy
1NubianRichest flavour Check price for Nubian →
2Nigerian DwarfBest for a small holding Check price for Nigerian Dwarf →
3AlpineBest all-rounder
4SaanenHighest volume

Richest flavour

Nubian

The default answer for flavour, and the right one for a household making cheese. Be honest with yourself about the noise.

Butterfat
4–5%
Volume
Moderate
Temperament
Vocal, affectionate, demanding
Climate
Tolerates heat well

What we liked

  • Highest butterfat of the common full-size dairy breeds
  • Milk tastes noticeably sweet and creamy
  • Excellent for cheese and butter yield per litre
  • Handles hot climates better than Swiss breeds

Worth knowing

  • Markedly louder than other breeds — a real neighbour consideration
  • Lower milk volume than Saanen or Alpine
Check current price (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)

Best for a small holding

Nigerian Dwarf

What we would keep on a small plot. Richer milk than a Nubian, in a goat a single person can handle.

Butterfat
6%+
Volume
Low, but high for size
Temperament
Friendly, manageable
Size
Around 20–34 kg

What we liked

  • Very high butterfat, often above the Nubian
  • Small enough to handle easily and to keep on little land
  • Long lactations relative to size
  • Quieter than Nubians

Worth knowing

  • Small teats make hand milking fiddly
  • Absolute volume is low — may need two does
Check current price (affiliate link, opens in a new tab)

Best all-rounder

Alpine

The sensible choice if volume matters more than richness. Mild rather than rich.

Butterfat
~3.5%
Volume
High
Temperament
Hardy, independent
Climate
Very adaptable

What we liked

  • Strong milk production over long lactations
  • Hardy and adaptable to varied conditions
  • Clean mild flavour when well handled

Worth knowing

  • Lower butterfat means thinner milk and less cheese per litre
  • Can be pushy in a mixed herd

Highest volume

Saanen

More milk than a household can drink, and the least rich of the four. Good for volume, not for flavour.

Butterfat
~3%
Volume
Highest
Temperament
Calm, docile
Climate
Dislikes strong sun

What we liked

  • The production breed — most milk of any dairy goat
  • Calm and easy to handle

Worth knowing

  • Lowest butterfat, so the mildest and thinnest milk
  • Pale skin is prone to sunburn; needs shade

Common questions

Which goat breed has the best tasting milk?

Nubians are the usual answer, because their milk carries the highest butterfat of the common dairy breeds — typically four to five per cent against around three for Alpines and Saanens — and fat is what makes milk taste rich and sweet rather than thin. Nigerian Dwarfs are comparable or higher on butterfat and are popular for the same reason on a smaller scale. That said, handling makes a larger difference to flavour than breed does, and badly handled Nubian milk tastes worse than carefully handled Saanen.

Why does goat milk taste goaty?

Usually because of how it was handled rather than the goat. Goat milk picks up odours readily, and the fat globules are small and fragile, so milk left standing warm, cooled slowly, or stored near strong-smelling food develops the characteristic tang people object to. The other major cause is a buck kept close to the does, since the compounds responsible for his smell transfer into the milk. Fresh milk, filtered and chilled fast, from does kept away from bucks, tastes clean and sweet.

Does butterfat make goat milk taste better?

It makes it taste richer and sweeter, which most people describe as better. Fat carries flavour and gives milk body, so a four to five per cent butterfat Nubian milk tastes creamy where a three per cent Saanen milk tastes lighter and thinner. Higher butterfat also means more cheese and more butter per litre, which matters if the milk is going into anything beyond the glass. The trade-off is volume, since the highest-butterfat breeds generally give less milk overall.

Which dairy goat gives the most milk?

Saanens, generally — they are the production breed of the dairy goat world, giving high volumes of lower-butterfat milk, with Alpines close behind and more adaptable to varied conditions. Nubians give less volume at higher butterfat, and Nigerian Dwarfs give considerably less in absolute terms but a surprising amount for their size. For a household, the quantity question usually matters less than people expect, since even a modest doe produces more milk than one family drinks.

What affects goat milk flavour most?

Handling first, buck management second, feed third, and breed fourth. Milk filtered and chilled within minutes tastes clean; milk left to cool slowly does not. A buck housed near the does taints the milk regardless of everything else. Strong feeds such as brassicas, wild garlic and some silages carry through into flavour. Breed sets the richness through butterfat, but it cannot rescue milk that was mishandled.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading