Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Wild Birds

Is It Good to Have Birds in Your Backyard? Mostly Yes

Birds eat pests, pollinate and spread seed — and peck fruit, foul patios and strip lawns. The honest ledger, and how to tilt it.

By Salma 2 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab
A blue tit perched on a budding forsythia branch dusted with snow
Photo: BMeyendriesch, Pixabay Content License, via Pixabay
On this page

A garden with birds in it has free pest control, a pollination assist and a seed-dispersal service. It also has pecked raspberries and a spotted patio. The ledger comes out well ahead for most gardens, and the debits are mostly placeable.

The ledger

creditdebit
Caterpillar and aphid controlPecked soft fruit
Slug and snail predationBrassica seedlings stripped
Leatherjacket and chafer grub removalTurf lifted while they do it
Flying-insect controlDroppings on patio, car, washing
Seed dispersal, some pollinationDawn chorus in the bedroom

What they will and will not control

pestbirds help
Caterpillarsstrongly
Aphidsmoderately
Leatherjackets, chafer grubsstrongly
Slugs, snailsmoderately
Vine weevil adultsmoderately
Root aphids, stem borersno
Red spider miteno

Lawn damage is a diagnosis, not a nuisance

Birds pulling at turf in autumn and early spring are telling you there are grubs beneath. Netting the lawn or scaring the birds leaves the grubs in place, and the turf goes brown in the first dry spell because the roots are gone.

Tilting the balance

  • Net the fruit two weeks before it colours, not after the first peck
  • Site feeders downwind and away from seating, washing lines and parked cars
  • Use sunflower hearts rather than husked mixes so there is no hull mat underneath
  • Add water — a shallow dish, sloping, under 5 cm deep, rinsed every few days
  • Keep one scruffy corner — the insects the birds need have to live somewhere

One nest box, facing north to east

A box on a north-to-east-facing wall avoids afternoon sun and driving rain, which is the commonest reason an occupied box fails. Put it 2–4 m up, clear of a branch a cat can use, and leave it alone once there is activity.

Common questions

Are birds good for a garden overall?

For most gardens, clearly yes. A breeding pair of blue tits or chickadees takes several hundred caterpillars a day while feeding chicks, and that is the single largest free pest-control input a small garden gets. Swallows and swifts work the airspace for flying insects, thrushes and blackbirds take slugs and snails, and woodpeckers strip wood-boring larvae. The costs are real but smaller and more localised.

What are the actual downsides?

Four, in rough order of how often people complain: pecked soft fruit and brassica seedlings, droppings on patios, cars and washing, lawn damage from birds digging for leatherjackets and chafer grubs, and noise at dawn in spring. Pigeons and gulls add a scale problem that songbirds do not — they concentrate, and their droppings are corrosive.

Do birds eat the pests I actually have?

Many of them. Caterpillars, aphids, leatherjackets, chafer grubs, vine weevil adults, sawfly larvae, slugs and snails are all taken by common garden species. What birds do not control is anything that lives inside the plant — stem borers, root aphids, gall-forming insects — and they will not touch a slug population that is breeding under a permanently damp mulch.

Why are birds digging up my lawn?

Because something edible is under it. Scattered small holes and lifted turf usually mean leatherjackets or chafer grubs, and the birds are a symptom rather than the problem. The grubs are the thing to deal with; chase the birds off and the lawn still fails in midsummer when the roots have been eaten through.

Will feeding birds make the downsides worse?

It changes which birds you get rather than simply adding more. Feeders concentrate starlings, house sparrows and pigeons, which are the species most likely to foul a patio. Feeding with sunflower hearts rather than cheap mixes, siting the feeder away from the seating area, and keeping a ground tray rather than a scatter point all shift the balance toward the birds doing the useful work.

What is the single best thing to add?

Water, if there is none. A shallow dish changed every couple of days brings in more species than any feeder, is used year-round by birds that never touch seed, and costs nothing. After that, a nest box facing between north and east, and one native berrying shrub.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading