Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Grilling & BBQ

What Can I Use Instead of Charcoal? Four That Work

Hardwood, charcoal briquettes from other sources, a gas conversion or an electric grill all work. What never works is construction timber or lighter fuel alone.

By Zakaria 3 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab
Cast iron pots hanging over an open wood fire burning down to embers
Photo: Pexels, Pixabay Content License, via Pixabay
On this page

Seasoned hardwood burned down to embers is the closest substitute — it is also the original method. Gas and electric remove the question entirely. What never works is construction timber, or trying to cook over lighter fluid.

The options

This table answers the question on its own
FuelFlavourHeatWaitNotes
Seasoned hardwoodBestUneven30–45 minThe original method
Lump charcoalVery goodHot, fast15–20 minLess ash, burns out sooner
BriquettesGoodSteady, long20–30 minSuits slow cooking
GasFairInstant, controllableNoneAdd a smoker box
ElectricLeastControllableNoneWhere fire is prohibited
Cast iron griddle indoorsFairControllableNoneReal searing, no smoke

Never cook over flames, only over embers

Flames deposit soot on the food and scorch the outside before the inside cooks. With wood that means waiting for the fire to burn down to glowing embers — which is most of the extra time wood costs you.

Which woods

Use: oak, hickory, maple, ash, beech, and fruit woods such as apple and cherry. Seasoned, dry, and unpainted.

Avoid:

  • Treated, painted, stained or glued timber — construction lumber, plywood, chipboard, MDF
  • Pallets of unknown origin — frequently treated
  • Softwoods such as pine and spruce — not toxic, but resinous, spitting, and they taste of turpentine

Lighter fluid is not a fuel, it is a starter

Food cooked while lighter fluid is still burning off tastes of it. Let the coals ash over completely before anything goes on — or use a chimney starter and skip the fluid entirely.

Lump or briquettes

  • Lump: lights faster, burns hotter, less ash. Searing. Burns out sooner and less evenly.
  • Briquettes: uniform, longer, steadier temperature. Slow cooking. Some contain binders that produce more ash.

For ordinary grilling either is fine; the choice is really about how long you need the heat to hold.

Gas and electric

Gas gives immediate, controllable, consistent heat with no ash. What it does not reproduce is the flavour of fat dripping onto hot coals — though a smoker box of wood chips recovers a useful part of it.

Electric uses an element rather than combustion, which is why it is often the only option permitted on balconies and in rented properties where charcoal and gas are banned. Check the rules before buying anything.

Common questions

What can you use instead of charcoal?

Seasoned hardwood burned down to embers is the closest substitute and the original method, giving excellent flavour at the cost of a longer wait and a less even heat. Beyond that, lump charcoal and briquettes are interchangeable with each other, a gas or electric grill removes the question entirely, and for small quantities a cast iron griddle on a hob does the job indoors. What should never be used is construction timber, painted or treated wood, pallets of unknown origin, or any attempt to cook over lighter fluid.

Can you grill with wood instead of charcoal?

Yes, and it predates charcoal grilling, but the technique differs. Wood must be burned down to a bed of glowing embers before cooking, which takes perhaps 30 to 45 minutes, because cooking over flames rather than embers deposits soot on the food and scorches the outside before the inside is done. Use seasoned hardwood — oak, hickory, maple, fruit woods — and expect a less even and less predictable heat than charcoal gives.

What wood should you never grill with?

Anything treated, painted, stained or glued: construction timber, plywood, chipboard, MDF and pallets of unknown origin all release harmful compounds into the smoke and therefore into the food. Softwoods such as pine and spruce are not toxic but are resinous, so they burn fast, spit, and give an unpleasant turpentine-like flavour. Stick to seasoned hardwoods, and avoid any wood that has been in contact with chemicals.

Is lump charcoal better than briquettes?

They suit different jobs rather than one being better. Lump charcoal lights faster, burns hotter and leaves less ash, which suits high-heat searing, but it burns less evenly and does not last as long. Briquettes are uniform, burn longer and hold a steadier temperature, which suits slow cooking, though some contain binders and fillers that produce more ash. For most domestic grilling either works, and the choice is mostly about how long you need the heat to hold.

Can you use a gas grill instead of charcoal?

Yes, and for most everyday cooking the difference in results is smaller than the debate suggests. Gas gives immediate, controllable, consistent heat with no waiting and no ash, which is why it suits weeknight cooking. What it does not reproduce is the flavour from fat dripping onto hot coals and the smoke that produces. A smoker box of wood chips on a gas grill recovers a worthwhile part of that.

Can you grill without any fuel at all?

An electric grill uses an element rather than combustion, which makes it usable where fire is not permitted — many balconies and rented properties prohibit charcoal and gas but allow electric. Indoors, a heavy cast iron griddle pan on a hob gives genuine searing and grill marks. Neither produces smoke flavour, but both solve the practical problem of wanting grilled food without a fire.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading