Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Herbs

What Herbs Grow Well Together in the Same Container

Group herbs by what they want, not by what you cook with. Mediterranean herbs in one pot, thirsty soft herbs in another, and mint always alone.

By Salma 3 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab
Herb container garden
Photo: cocoparisienne, Pixabay Content License, via Pixabay
On this page

The usual mistake is grouping herbs by what you cook with — a pot of basil, rosemary and mint for the pasta. Those three want three incompatible things, and within a season you will have one healthy plant and two casualties.

The two groups

Group by conditions and the pot looks after itself
Mediterranean potSoft herb pot
HerbsRosemary, thyme, oregano, sage, marjoramBasil, parsley, chives, coriander
CompostGritty, free-draining, leanRicher, moisture-retentive
WaterInfrequent; let it dryConsistently moist
SunFull, 6+ hrsFull to light shade
FeedVery littleBalanced liquid, every 3–4 weeks
LifePerennialAnnual / biennial

The split is ecological. The first group comes from dry Mediterranean hillsides — poor stony soil, blazing sun, long dry spells. The second group wants moist, fertile ground and bolts or wilts under stress.

There is no watering schedule that serves both.

Why basil and rosemary specifically fails

It is worth spelling out because it is the single commonest herb-pot pairing.

Water it to suit the basil — consistently moist — and the rosemary’s roots sit damp, which is how rosemary dies. It rots at the base, usually over weeks, and often is blamed on cold.

Water it to suit the rosemary — dry out between soakings — and the basil wilts, toughens, and bolts to flower early, which ends its useful life.

Each plant is fine. The pot is the problem.

Mint is not a sharing plant

Mint spreads by rhizomes — underground runners that travel sideways and send up new shoots wherever they surface. In a bed it takes over a border. In a shared pot there is nowhere else to go, so it simply fills the entire root volume and starves its neighbours of water and nutrients.

It is also the one herb that genuinely prefers part shade and damp soil, so giving it a pot of its own lets you site it where it does best — a corner where the others would sulk.

The pot itself

Twelve inches across and twelve deep is the minimum for three or four herbs, and bigger is meaningfully better. Two reasons:

  1. Small pots dry out within hours in summer heat. For basil that irregular wet-dry cycle is what triggers bolting; for everything it means stress
  2. A larger soil volume buffers root temperature. A small dark pot in full sun cooks

Drainage holes are non-negotiable, and a shallow trough is a bad choice for rosemary or sage, which are shrubs with real root systems rather than bedding plants.

Feeding: less than you think

This is where the two groups diverge again, and it is counterintuitive for the Mediterranean set.

Rosemary, thyme and oregano grown lean produce more essential oil — which is to say, more flavour. Feed them well and you get a big, soft, bland plant. Poor gritty compost and no feeding is the correct treatment.

Basil, parsley and coriander do want a balanced liquid feed every three or four weeks through the growing season, because they are producing soft leaf continuously.

Planning for next year

Mixing annuals and perennials in one pot means tearing up established roots each spring to replant the basil.

So if you want a pot that lasts: build it from perennials — rosemary, thyme, sage, oregano, chives — and keep basil and coriander in their own container to be replanted each year. Parsley is a biennial that bolts in its second summer, so treat it as annual too.

Common questions

What herbs grow well together in the same container?

Group them by growing conditions rather than by culinary use. Rosemary, thyme, oregano, sage and marjoram all want full sun, gritty free-draining compost and infrequent watering, so they share a pot happily. Basil, parsley, chives and coriander want richer compost and consistently moist soil, so they belong together in a different pot. Mint should always be grown alone, because its runners will fill any container it shares and starve everything else.

Can you plant basil and rosemary together?

It is the classic mistake, and it fails because they want opposite conditions. Rosemary is a Mediterranean shrub that wants gritty soil kept on the dry side and will rot if kept damp; basil is a soft tender annual that wilts the moment it dries out. Watering the pot to suit the basil slowly kills the rosemary, and watering to suit the rosemary leaves the basil permanently stressed. Use two pots — it is far easier than compromising.

Why does mint take over a container?

Mint spreads by rhizomes, underground runners that travel sideways and send up new shoots wherever they go. In open ground it colonises a bed; in a shared container there is nowhere else to go, so it fills the entire root volume within a season and the other herbs are starved of water and nutrients. The solution is simply a pot of its own, which also means you can site it in the part shade and moisture it actually prefers.

How big should a shared herb container be?

At least twelve inches across and twelve deep for three or four herbs, and larger is genuinely better. Small pots dry out within hours in summer heat, which stresses soft herbs badly and causes the irregular watering that makes basil bolt. A bigger soil volume also buffers temperature at the roots. Drainage holes are non-negotiable, and a shallow trough is a poor choice for rosemary or sage, which are shrubs with real root systems.

Should herbs in a container be fertilised?

Lightly, and less than most container plants. Mediterranean herbs grown hard in poor gritty soil produce far more essential oil and therefore more flavour, so feeding rosemary, thyme and oregano heavily gives you a large bland plant. Soft herbs such as basil and parsley do appreciate a balanced liquid feed every three or four weeks in the growing season, which is another reason to keep the two groups in separate pots.

Which herbs are perennial and which need replacing each year?

Rosemary, thyme, sage, oregano, marjoram, chives and mint are perennial and persist for years, while basil and coriander are annuals that die after one season, and parsley is a biennial usually grown as an annual because it bolts in its second year. Mixing annuals and perennials in one pot means disturbing established roots every spring to replant, so if you want a single long-lived pot, build it from perennials and keep basil and coriander in their own container.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading