Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Vegetables

Types of Gardening Methods — 8 and What Each Suits

Types of gardening methods come down to 8 real choices, from no-dig to hydroponics. What each costs in space, water and effort, and which fits your ground.

By Salma 4 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab
Young bean seedlings emerging through mulch in a raised bed
Photo: 13467596, Pixabay Content License, via Pixabay
On this page

Most of what gets called a gardening method is a decision about one of three things: whether you disturb the soil, how you divide the space, and where the water goes. Eight approaches cover practically every garden.

The eight

Space, water and effort by method
MethodSpace neededWater useSetup costOngoing effort
In-groundLargeModerateLowestHigh — weeding scales with area
No-digAnyModerateCompost each yearLowest after year 2
Raised bedSmall–mediumModerateHigh — frame and fillLow
ContainerMinimalHighestModerateDaily watering in summer
Square foot4 ft × 4 ftModerateModerateLow, with planning
VerticalMinimal footprintModerateFrameTying in, pruning
HügelkulturMediumLow once settledLabour, not moneyLow
HydroponicSmallLowestHighestDaily checks, power

1. In-ground. Dig, amend, plant. The cheapest way to start and the most work to maintain, because every square foot is a square foot to weed. It is the right answer when you already have good soil and want area.

2. No-dig. Leave the soil structure alone and add compost on top, two inches a year. Weed germination drops because buried seed is never brought up, and earthworm burrows and fungal networks stay intact. The cost is the compost supply, which for a 4 ft by 8 ft bed is roughly five cubic feet a year.

3. Raised beds. A frame filled with a mix you control, which removes native soil from the equation entirely. Warms earlier in spring, drains faster, and is easier on the back. It also dries out faster in high summer, which is the trade people forget.

4. Containers. The only option on a balcony or paving, and the thirstiest thing in this list — a 12-inch pot in July can need watering twice a day. Everything the plant gets, you supply.

5. Square foot. A 4 ft by 4 ft bed on a one-foot grid, with a planting density set per square. It works because 4 ft is the widest a bed can be while remaining reachable from both sides, so nobody ever stands on the soil.

6. Vertical. Not a soil method but a space one: trellises, arches and wall systems for anything that climbs. Beans, cucumbers, squash and tomatoes take up a fraction of the ground and stay cleaner and less mildewed for the airflow.

7. Hügelkultur. A mound built over buried logs and woody debris, which rots slowly and holds water like a sponge. Takes a season to settle and a good deal of initial labour, and then needs very little irrigation.

8. Hydroponics. Roots in nutrient solution rather than soil. Fastest growth, least water, highest setup cost, and a dependence on power — a pump failure in warm weather can lose a crop in a day.

Tip

If you are choosing a first method, choose by your weakest input rather than your goal. Poor or unknown soil points at raised beds, no ground at all points at containers, little time points at no-dig, and little water points at mulch and hügelkultur. The crop list barely changes between them.

Where they overlap

The methods are not exclusive, and treating them as rival philosophies is the commonest way to overcomplicate a garden.

  • No-dig inside raised beds is the standard productive setup: a frame, filled once, then top-dressed with compost and never turned.
  • Square foot is a spacing scheme, so it sits inside a raised bed or an in-ground plot equally.
  • Vertical goes into all of them, and in a small garden it is the single highest-return addition.

Only hydroponics stands apart, because it removes the soil the other seven are all arguments about.

Common questions

What is the easiest gardening method for a beginner?

Raised beds filled with bought compost, or containers if space is tight. Both sidestep the single hardest variable for a beginner, which is unknown native soil, and they give a short, clearly bounded area to keep weeded. The method that fails most beginners is a large in-ground plot, because the weeding load scales with area and the first season is when enthusiasm is spent fastest.

Is no-dig gardening actually better?

For established beds, generally yes. Leaving soil structure intact preserves fungal networks and earthworm burrows, and a mulch of compost suppresses weed germination, so the ongoing work drops sharply after the first two seasons. The costs are real though: it needs a steady supply of compost, and it is slower to fix compaction than one deep initial loosening would be.

How much space does square foot gardening need?

A 4 ft by 4 ft bed gives sixteen squares, which is enough for a continuous supply of salad, herbs and a few roots for one or two people. The method works because 4 ft is the widest a bed can be while still being reachable from both sides without stepping on it, which is what keeps the soil uncompacted.

Which gardening method uses the least water?

Hydroponics, by a wide margin — recirculating systems use roughly a tenth of the water of in-ground growing for the same crop, because nothing drains away or evaporates from soil. Among soil methods, deep mulch over in-ground beds is the most frugal, since mulch cuts surface evaporation substantially. Containers are the thirstiest option by a long way.

Can you combine gardening methods?

Most productive gardens do. No-dig and square foot are entirely compatible, raised beds are a container for whichever soil method you run inside them, and a vertical trellis belongs in any of them. The methods describe how you handle soil, space and water, and only hydroponics genuinely excludes the others.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading