Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Fish & Ponds

Why Aren't Fish Biting? Six Causes, in Order of Likelihood

Water temperature, barometric pressure, light and feeding windows explain most blank sessions. What to change, and what is outside your control.

By Salma 2 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab
Two anglers silhouetted in a boat on a misted lake at sunrise
Photo: GuentherDillingen, Pixabay Content License, via Pixabay
On this page

Most blank sessions are explained by water temperature, time of day, and what the weather did yesterday — not by the bait on the hook.

The six causes, ranked

causehow to tell
Water temperature outside the rangethermometer; species range
Wrong time of dayflat bright midday, no surface activity
Post-cold-front high pressureclear bright sky, sharp drop yesterday
Fishing the wrong depthno contact at any speed
Spawningfish visible but ignoring everything
Fishing pressurebusy bank, water worked that morning

Temperature ranges worth knowing

speciesfeeds bestshuts down
Trout10–16°Cabove ~20°C
Bass18–27°Cbelow ~10°C
Carp18–24°Cbelow ~8°C
Pike10–18°Cabove ~22°C
Panfish15–24°Cbelow ~8°C

Air temperature is a poor proxy. Shallow water warms and cools several times faster than deep water, so the same lake can be in range at one end and out of it at the other.

Change depth before you change anything else

Far more blanks are caused by presenting above the fish than by the wrong lure. In cold, bright or post-front conditions they sit deeper than most people fish, and they will not come up for it.

What to do with a shut-down day

  • Fish the approach of weather rather than the clear day behind it
  • Go at first light or last light and accept that the middle of the day is poor
  • Slow everything down in cold water — a cold fish will not chase
  • Downsize before you change colour
  • Move, rather than persisting; a blank spot stays a blank spot
  • Come back at dusk if the day has been bright and still

An algal bloom crashes the oxygen at night

In warm still weather, a heavy bloom photosynthesises by day and respires by night, and dissolved oxygen bottoms out before dawn. Fish are lethargic and feeding stops. It is one of the conditions where nothing in the tackle box is the answer.

Common questions

Why are the fish not biting?

Most often because of water temperature, the time of day, or a recent change in barometric pressure. Fish are ectothermic, so their metabolism and therefore their appetite track water temperature closely — too cold and they barely feed, too warm and oxygen drops and they stop. Add the fact that most species feed hardest at dawn and dusk, and a blank midday session in flat conditions is explained without any reference to bait or technique.

Does barometric pressure really matter?

The pattern anglers report consistently is that feeding improves on falling pressure ahead of a front and shuts down sharply for a day or so after a cold front passes and pressure rises. The mechanism is debated — effects on swim bladders at shallow depths are one proposed explanation — but the practical rule is well established enough to plan around: fish the approach of weather, not the clear bright day behind it.

What water temperature stops fish feeding?

It depends entirely on the species, which is why a single number misleads. Trout feed best around 10–16°C and shut down above about 20°C. Bass are most active around 18–27°C and sluggish below 10°C. Carp barely feed below about 8°C. The useful habit is to learn the range for the species you are after and carry a thermometer, rather than judging by air temperature, which can differ from the water by a long way.

When is the best time of day?

The hour either side of sunrise and of sunset, for most freshwater species. Low light favours the predator over the prey, so feeding concentrates there. Overcast days extend the window considerably, which is why a grey drizzly day often fishes better than a bright still one. In high summer, night fishing where permitted is frequently better than anything in daylight.

What should I change first?

Depth, then retrieve speed, then size, then colour — in that order. Fish holding deeper than you are presenting is the single commonest reason for a blank, and in cold or bright conditions they are almost always deeper than people fish. Slowing the retrieve is next, because cold fish will not chase. Downsizing the bait comes before changing its colour, which matters far less than anglers believe.

When is it not your fault?

After a cold front, during a sharp temperature drop, in a heavy algal bloom when oxygen crashes, during a spawn when fish are defending rather than feeding, and in heavily pressured water that has been fished hard that morning. Several conditions genuinely shut feeding down, and persisting through them with ever-smaller baits is usually wasted effort. Coming back at dusk is the better answer.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading

A farm pond with cattails along the near bank, a red barn and open pasture behind it
Backyard Animals ·

How Big a Pond Do You Need for Bass?

Half an acre and eight feet deep is the practical floor for a self-sustaining bass pond. What smaller ponds can and cannot support.

A carp clearing the surface of a lake in a burst of spray
Backyard Animals ·

Why Do Fish Jump Out of the Water?

Feeding, escaping predators, shedding parasites, and clearing obstacles — plus the one reason that matters if it is your pond fish doing it.