Petting Deer: Why the Tame One in Your Yard Is the Dangerous One
A deer that lets you approach has lost its fear of people, and that is when injuries happen. What the risks are, and why feeding starts the sequence.
By 
On this page
The deer that lets you walk up to it is the one to be careful of. Tameness in a wild deer is not affection — it is a lost flight response, and that is the animal that injures people.
Why the tame one is the problem
A wild deer’s default is to leave. That wariness is what keeps both of you safe, and feeding removes it — first for the person feeding, then for everyone.
What a habituated deer does:
- Approaches people expecting food
- Does not retreat when it should
- Becomes assertive when the food does not appear — striking with forefeet is common
- Passes the behaviour on, since fawns learn it from the doe
- Ends up killed. Deer that injure people are usually destroyed
The two windows where deer actually injure people
Autumn rut, September to December. Bucks are flooded with testosterone, antlers are hard, and an animal that ignored you in July will charge in November.
Late spring, fawning. A doe defends a fawn against dogs and people with her forefeet, and does so without much warning.
Outside those, deer mostly run. Inside them, a habituated deer is genuinely hazardous.
What they weigh, and what that means
An adult white-tailed deer is commonly 100 to 300 pounds, with hooves sharp enough to cut and the speed to use them. A buck’s antlers are weapons he is actively looking to use in autumn.
Recorded injuries include broken ribs, punctured organs, deep lacerations and fatalities. They are rare, and they are concentrated in encounters with animals that had stopped being afraid.
Disease, which is the quieter reason
- Ticks. Deer carry them in large numbers, including black-legged ticks transmitting Lyme disease, anaplasmosis and babesiosis. Close contact raises exposure
- Chronic wasting disease. Not known to transmit to humans, but health authorities advise against handling or eating infected animals — a fair argument against handling deer generally
- Parasites and bacteria — a range, including some that pass to livestock and pets
- Bovine tuberculosis in some regions
If a deer approaches you
- Back away slowly. Keep facing it
- Put something solid between you — a car, a tree, a fence
- Do not run, and do not turn your back
- Do not offer food. That is usually what it came for
- If it keeps coming, make yourself large and loud. The aim is to restore the wariness
- Read the warnings: a buck with lowered head, raised hackles or ears back, a doe stamping a foot or blowing — those are not opening signals, they are escalations
Fawns
A fawn lying alone is doing exactly what it should
A doe leaves her fawn still and alone for most of the day and returns only to nurse. The fawn is nearly scentless, and lying motionless is its entire defence strategy.
Picking it up is the usual reason a healthy fawn ends up orphaned. Human scent can cause a doe to abandon, and a fawn “rescued” from a garden is almost always a fawn stolen from a mother standing fifty yards away waiting for you to leave.
Call a licensed wildlife rehabilitator only if the fawn is visibly injured, covered in flies, crying continuously for hours, or lying beside a dead doe.
Otherwise: leave it, keep dogs in, and watch from a distance.
Feeding, and why agencies ban it
Beyond habituation, it harms the animals directly:
- Winter acidosis. A deer’s rumen in winter is adapted to woody browse, and a sudden load of corn or grain can be fatal. Deer are found dead with full stomachs of supplied feed
- Disease concentration. A feed site puts many animals nose to nose, which is how chronic wasting disease and parasites move
- Roads. Feeding draws deer toward houses and the roads beside them
- Local overpopulation, and the browse damage that follows
Many state wildlife agencies restrict or ban feeding outright. Check yours before putting anything out — in some places it is an offence.
Watching them properly
- Binoculars. You see more of the actual animal than you would at three feet
- Sit still at dawn or dusk, at the edge of cover, and let them come past
- Plant for them away from the house if you want them around, and fence the garden
- Dogs in. Loose dogs cause most fawn deaths in suburban areas, and provoke most defensive does
- Drive carefully at dawn and dusk in autumn. Vehicle collisions are how deer actually kill people, in numbers nothing else here comes close to
Common questions
Can you pet a deer?
Are deer dangerous to people?
Is it safe to touch a deer?
What should I do if a deer approaches me?
Why is feeding deer a bad idea?
I found a fawn alone — can I touch it?
Backyard Weekly
Know what to plant, week by week
Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.
Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.
By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.
Keep reading
Can a Deer Kill You? The Honest Risk, and When to Worry
Deer kill more people than bears and snakes combined — almost all in car collisions. Direct attacks are rare but real. When a deer is genuinely dangerous.
Do Deer Attack Humans? Rarely, But Not Never
Deer injure more people than most wild animals in North America — almost all of it in autumn rut or from a doe with a fawn. What provokes it and what to do.
How to Attract Deer to Your Property (Legally and Well)
Deer come for food, water, cover and quiet — in that order. What to plant, what they actually like, and why baiting is the wrong first move.
Pros and Cons of Feeding Squirrels: An Honest Accounting
Feeding squirrels is enjoyable and mostly harmless to them — the costs land on your roof, your bird feeders, your neighbours and your bulbs.