Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Chickens

Can Layers and Meat Chickens Live Together? Usually Not Well

Different feed, different growth rates, different lifespans. Where a mixed pen works, where it harms both, and the dual-purpose alternative.

By Zakaria 2 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab
A cockerel and a black hen feeding head-down at the same corn cob
Photo: ignartonosbg, Pixabay Content License, via Pixabay
On this page

They will not fight. They will eat the wrong food, which is a slower and more expensive problem than fighting.

Why the rations conflict

meat birdslayers
Protein20–24%16–18%
Calciumlowhigh
Wrong feed causespoor growth, leg problemssoft shells, kidney strain
Time to finish6–8 wks (Cornish Cross)lays for years
Activitylowhigh

Which meat birds mix, and which do not

birdmixes with layers
Cornish Crossno
Ranger / Freedom Rangerreasonably
Traditional meat breedsyes
Dual-purpose breedsno mixing needed

Flock-raiser plus free-choice oyster shell

One feed at 18–20% protein and low calcium, with crushed oyster shell in a separate dish. Laying hens take what they need and the others ignore it. This is how most mixed-age flocks are run, and it works for everything except Cornish Cross.

The welfare argument people miss

Fast-grown meat birds carry leg weakness and heart strain as a consequence of the growth rate. A pen of active layers means competition at the feeder and more movement than a struggling broiler can manage well. Separating by age matters too — young stock mixed with adults picks up coccidiosis and Marek’s more readily, which is why most keepers end up separating by age before they separate by purpose.

Decide the processing date before you buy

Cornish Cross kept past about ten weeks develops serious leg and heart problems. “We will see how it goes” is not a plan with this bird — the schedule is part of the purchase.

Common questions

Can meat birds and laying hens be kept in the same pen?

They can physically share space without fighting, but it usually damages both. The problem is feed: fast-growing broilers need 20–24% protein and layers need 16–18% with far more calcium. Feed the broiler ration to layers and you get soft-shelled eggs and kidney strain from excess protein; feed the layer ration to broilers and they grow poorly, and the calcium load is bad for birds that are not laying.

What about Cornish Cross specifically?

Cornish Cross is the worst case for mixing. It reaches slaughter weight in six to eight weeks, barely moves, eats almost continuously and cannot compete at a feeder with active layers — or dominates it by sitting there. It also produces a great deal of manure in a short time, which fouls bedding faster than a layer flock's. Keep it separately, and plan to process it on schedule rather than keeping it on.

Are slower-growing meat birds easier to mix?

Considerably. Ranger-type broilers, Freedom Rangers and traditional meat breeds grow over twelve to sixteen weeks, forage properly and behave much more like layers. Mixing those with hens works reasonably well in practice, particularly if both are on a flock-raiser ration with oyster shell offered separately for the layers to self-select.

What is the flock-raiser compromise?

A single grower or flock-raiser feed at around 18–20% protein with low calcium, fed to everything, with crushed oyster shell in a separate dish that laying hens take as they need it. Hens regulate calcium intake well when it is offered free-choice. This is the standard way of running a mixed-age, mixed-purpose flock, and it works — just not with Cornish Cross, whose protein needs are too high.

Is a dual-purpose breed a better idea?

For most backyard keepers, yes. A Sussex, Orpington, Plymouth Rock, Wyandotte or Australorp lays respectably and carries enough meat to be worth processing, on one feed, in one pen, with one set of decisions. The meat is slower-grown and less tender than a broiler's and there is markedly less of it — but it removes the whole mixing problem.

Are there disease or welfare reasons to separate them?

Yes, two. Meat birds grown fast are prone to leg weakness and heart failure, and a mixed pen with active layers means more movement and competition than a struggling broiler can manage. And keeping birds of very different ages together raises the risk of passing coccidiosis and Marek's to younger stock — the separation most keepers eventually settle on is by age as much as by purpose.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading