Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Ducks

Best Ducks for Eggs: Five Breeds, and What Each Costs You

A Khaki Campbell out-lays almost any chicken. Five laying breeds compared on eggs per year, noise, temperament and how long the output actually holds up.

By Zakaria 3 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab
An upright Runner-type duck standing among a mixed backyard flock of ducks and hens
Photo: Gundula Vogel, Pexels License, via Pexels
On this page

The Khaki Campbell, at roughly 280–320 eggs a year — more than most laying hens. Welsh Harlequins come close and are calmer. The cost is noise and no meat worth having.

The five

Laying ducks compared
BreedEggs/yearBuildTemperamentNotes
Khaki Campbell280–320LightActive, flightyThe production choice. Loud
Welsh Harlequin240–330LightCalmNearly a Campbell, easier to live with
Indian Runner250–300Light, uprightNervous, busyBest forager. Comic to watch
Ancona210–280MediumCalmHardy; broken colour markings
Pekin140–220HeavyCalm, docileDual-purpose. The common white duck

The pattern is consistent: the lighter the bird, the more eggs and the less meat. There is no breed that escapes it.

Duck against chicken

Worth putting plainly, because it is the reason people switch.

  • A good laying duck matches or beats a good laying hen on count, and the eggs are larger
  • Ducks keep going further into winter, and through weather that puts hens off lay
  • They lay early, usually before being let out, which makes collection simple

The trade is water and noise, not productivity

Ducks are messier than chickens by a wide margin — water is how they drink, clean and feed, and it goes everywhere.

And the laying breeds are loud. If either of those is a problem where you are, it is a better reason to reconsider than anything on the egg-count table.

Dual-purpose, honestly

Silver Appleyard, Saxony and Pekin are the usual recommendations, and all three are compromises by construction.

Expect roughly 150–250 eggs and a reasonable carcass. You are giving up about a hundred eggs a year against a Campbell, and the bird will still not match a purpose-bred broiler for meat.

That is a perfectly sensible trade for one flock doing two jobs. It is not a free one.

How long the laying lasts

  • Peak in years one and two, declining from the third
  • Ducks hold useful output longer than high-production hybrid hens
  • A well-kept Campbell may still lay respectably in its fourth year

Ducks outlive chickens, and a laying flock accumulates

A duck can live eight to twelve years. A flock kept for eggs therefore builds up retired birds unless that has been planned for.

Decide what happens to a four-year-old duck before you buy the ducklings, not after.

The eggs themselves

Larger, with a proportionally bigger yolk, more fat and more protein, and a thicker shell and membrane that keeps them longer.

Bakers generally prefer them — the extra fat and protein give richer cakes and better pastry. The white sets firmer when cooked, which some people dislike fried or poached. That is taste, not quality.

Common questions

Which duck breed lays the most eggs?

The Khaki Campbell, at roughly 280 to 320 eggs a year from a good strain — more than most laying hens. Welsh Harlequins come close and are calmer. Indian Runners are not far behind and are the best foragers of the group. All three are light breeds, which is the trade: they lay heavily and give almost nothing as table birds.

Do ducks lay better than chickens?

Often, and more consistently through the year. A good laying duck matches or beats a good laying hen on count, and duck eggs are larger. Ducks also tend to keep laying further into winter and through weather that puts hens off, and they usually lay early in the morning, which makes collection simpler. They are messier with water and louder, which is the other side of it.

What is the best dual-purpose duck?

Silver Appleyard and Saxony are the usual answers, with Pekin the common commercial choice. All three give a reasonable carcass and a fair number of eggs — roughly 150 to 250 a year depending on strain — without matching a Campbell on laying or a purpose-bred broiler on meat. A dual-purpose bird is a compromise by definition and should be chosen knowing that.

How long do laying ducks keep laying?

Production peaks in the first and second year and declines from the third, though ducks generally hold useful output longer than high-production hybrid hens do. A Campbell kept well may still be laying respectably in its fourth year. Ducks also live longer than chickens, so a laying flock accumulates retired birds unless that is planned for.

Are duck eggs different to chicken eggs?

They are larger, with a proportionally bigger yolk, more fat and more protein, and a thicker shell and membrane that makes them keep longer. Bakers generally prefer them, since the extra fat and protein give richer cakes and better pastry. The white is firmer when cooked, which some people dislike in a fried or poached egg.

Will laying ducks be too noisy for neighbours?

Females of the laying breeds are loud, and Campbells and Runners are among the loudest. A drake is quiet — the carrying quack is a female sound. Muscovies are the quiet option but lay far fewer eggs. If noise is the binding constraint, that trade is the one to think about before the egg count.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading