Skip to content
Grow In Backyard
Lawn Care

Ground Cover Instead of Grass: Options by Condition

Clover, creeping thyme, moss and sedum each suit different light, traffic and soil. What tolerates walking, what does not, and the real costs.

By Zakaria 2 min read Save to Pinterest — opens Pinterest in a new tab
A dense mat of creeping thyme in pink flower
Photo: silviarita, Pixabay Content License, via Pixabay
On this page

The right lawn alternative depends on three things: sun, traffic and drainage. Get those straight first — most failed replacements are a shade plant in sun or a mat plant on a path.

Options by condition

coversuntrafficmowingnotes
MicrocloverFull to partGood3–4×/yearFixes nitrogen; flowers attract bees
Clover + fine fescueFull to partGood4–6×/yearClosest thing to a conventional lawn
Creeping thymeFullLightNoneNeeds free drainage; aromatic underfoot
Dutch white cloverFull to partGood3–4×/yearTaller and flowers more than microclover
MossShadeNoneNoneWants damp, acidic, compacted ground
Sedum matFullNoneNoneLowest maintenance; no foot traffic
AjugaPart to shadeLightNoneSpreads fast; can invade beds
Creeping JennyPart to shadeLightNoneVigorous — contain it
Sweet woodruffShadeNoneNoneGood under trees
PachysandraShadeNoneNoneDense, slow to start

Clover flowers bring bees

For most households that is a benefit. If someone is allergic, or small children play barefoot on the lawn, choose microclover, which flowers far less, and mow before the flowers open — or pick fine fescue instead.

Replacing the lawn

  1. Remove the grass: smother with cardboard and mulch for a few months, lift with a sod cutter, or cultivate and rake out roots
  2. Prepare: loosen the top two to three inches, work in compost, level, firm
  3. Sow or plant: seed for clover and thyme; plugs at label spacing for spreading perennials
  4. Water as for new grass — light and frequent until established
  5. Weed through the first season, which is the part people underestimate
  6. Expect full cover in one to two seasons

Cost reality

  • Clover from seed is the cheapest route by a wide margin
  • Thyme or sedum plugs over any real area runs into serious money — keep those for small defined spaces
  • Savings arrive from year two: less water, no weekly mowing, no nitrogen feed on a clover cover

Common questions

What is the best grass alternative you can actually walk on?

Microclover or a clover-and-fescue blend for general use, and creeping thyme for lighter traffic in full sun. Microclover takes foot traffic close to as well as grass, stays green through dry spells because it roots deeply, fixes its own nitrogen so it needs no feeding, and is mown occasionally rather than weekly. Creeping thyme handles paths and stepping-stone gaps and smells good when trodden, but it will not take daily use from children or dogs.

What are the downsides of a clover lawn?

It flowers, which brings bees — pleasant for most people and a genuine problem if someone in the household is allergic or small children play barefoot. White clover is also shorter-lived than grass and patchy areas need reseeding every few years, it stains clothing more than grass does, and it goes dormant and looks sparse in deep shade. Microclover flowers less and stays lower than standard white clover, which addresses part of it.

What ground cover works in shade instead of grass?

Moss where it is damp and acidic, or creeping Jenny, sweet woodruff, ajuga and pachysandra in dry to moderate shade. None of them take real foot traffic, so plan stepping stones or a path through the area. Moss is the one most people overlook: in a shaded compacted site where grass has failed for years, encouraging the moss already there is cheaper and more successful than any further attempt at turf.

What is the lowest maintenance option overall?

Sedum and other succulent mats in full sun with free drainage, or moss in damp shade. Both need no mowing, no feeding and almost no water once established. The trade-off is traffic: neither recovers from being walked on. For an area that must be usable as well as low-maintenance, a clover-fescue blend mown three or four times a year is the realistic compromise.

How do I replace a lawn with ground cover?

Kill or remove the existing grass first — smother it with cardboard and mulch for a few months, lift it with a sod cutter, or cultivate and rake out the roots. Then prepare as you would for seeding: loosen the top two to three inches, work in compost, level and firm. Sow seed for clover or thyme, or plant plugs at the spacing on the label for spreading perennials. Expect one to two seasons to full cover, with weeding through the first one.

Will a ground cover lawn save money?

Over several years, generally yes — less water, no weekly mowing, no fertilizer for a nitrogen-fixing cover — but the establishment year costs more than overseeding a lawn, especially if you buy plugs rather than seed. Clover from seed is the cheapest route by a wide margin. Plug-planted thyme or sedum over any real area runs into serious money, which is why those suit small defined spaces rather than whole yards.

Backyard Weekly

Know what to plant, week by week

Join the weekly email for seasonal jobs, fixes for what is going wrong, and gear worth buying.

Not ready to subscribe? The planting calendar is free and needs no email.

By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy. Grow In Backyard will never sell your address.

Keep reading